Mafia: The Old Country Review
Ayyyy….we’re walking here!
Mafia: The Old Country is a stylish, story-driven return to form for the series, drenched in Sicilian atmosphere and brimming with classic mob drama. It’s gorgeous, engaging, and narratively rich, though its dated mechanics and linear design may leave some players wanting more.
Setting & Atmosphere
Instead of pushing forward into the ’70s or ’80s, Mafia: The Old Country rewinds to 1904 Sicily, the formative era of organized crime. The game blends mob drama with Western grit, immersing players in sun-baked vineyards, dusty roads, and sulfur mines. You can practically smell the sun-dried tomatoes in its richly detailed countryside. There’s even a Sicilian language option, which adds a layer of cultural immersion for players who want the full experience.
Story & Characters
You play as Enzo Favara, a young man escaping brutal labor in sulfur mines, only to fall into the orbit of the Torrisi crime family. Expect the wise mentor, the hot-headed nephew, the stern Don, the treacherous rival boss, and yes—the forbidden love interest. While the plot hits familiar beats, strong acting and thoughtful writing elevate the narrative.
Gameplay & Mechanics
Unlike the sprawling open world of Mafia III, this entry returns to a tight, story-driven format. The open world is more backdrop than playground, keeping the spotlight on narrative. Mechanics are serviceable but not groundbreaking. Gunfights, brawls, and stealth sequences keep the pacing varied, though some critics found them shallow. Driving is surprisingly enjoyable—cruising through Sicilian roads feels atmospheric, and you can skip long travel sequences if you prefer.
Final Verdict
Mafia: The Old Country is a love letter to the roots of organized crime storytelling, offering a moody, cinematic experience that feels more like an interactive film than a sandbox game. If you crave atmosphere, narrative, and character-driven drama, this is an offer you shouldn’t refuse. But if you’re looking for cutting-edge mechanics or expansive open-world freedom, you may find yourself longing for more.